As I mentioned earlier, you didn’t prove your point that “人类一夫一妻制是违反天性的。起码是反本类动物自然天性。说穿了就是统治的需要,而非人性的需要.”, using your so-called biological evidences. (Personally, I think you should do more research when saying no mammals are monogamous.)
Since you have failed to use these biological evidences to support your point that polygamy is more reasonable, (actually it is polygyny in your article), thus it is pointless to discuss about how many wives a man should take at the same time.
Now you are saying 伊斯兰教徒几千年就认同了这个理论4个老婆最安定, so do you mean you can use one culture to prove the reasonableness of polygamous? If not, it is pointless to write the whole article at all. If so, do you want to compare the cultures of Europe, which is monogamous at the beginning, 伊斯兰, and other places where Polyandry (a woman taking more than one husbands) exits, such as Tibet , the Canadian Arctic, Zanskar, Nepal, Ladakh, the Jaunsar region in Uttarakhand, India, Toda of South India,the Nymba, Nishi and Sri Lanka., some regions of Mongolia, China (especially Yunnan- the Mosuo people), and some Subsaharan African and American indigenous communities, and say which one is more reasonable? I think this will be a much better topic than your current one.
lao yan, i can't agree with you this time. a man can have 4 wives or more,but not at the same time.
flowerinthemirror 发表评论于
As for mammals that are genetically similar to humans- the primates, two monkeys--the marmoset and its South American cousin, the tamarin--that are genetically monogamous.
Thus it is not well grounded to draw the conclusion. :人类一夫一妻制是违反天性的。起码是反本类动物自然天性。说穿了就是统治的需要,而非人性的需要.
Further, there are caution against drawing simplistic conclusions about human biology from animal studies.
We must remember, "[Humans] have a big brain; we can decide all sorts of things. Just because there's biology does not mean we are destined to follow any particular biological route ."
flowerinthemirror 发表评论于
Re: 在哺乳类动物中没有一对斯守的物种
Although only a minority of mammals are monogamous,this system still exit, such as gray wolf. One benefit of mongamous system is that it can increase the reproductive success of the breeding pair. Both parents might be necessary for defense of the territory, feeding the young, warmth, and for the maintaining the socialization process.
In the gray wolf, this can easily be seen in teaching cooperative hunting and vocalizations to the young. The wolfpack inter-pack and intra-pack communication is extremely important for their survival. If they are unable to establish a territory, or kill larger ungulates, then they will be able to sustain themselves. Similarly, another strategy that will facilitate monogamous interactions is that wolves have a more prolonged dependence of their offspring. The cooperative hunting tactics and vocalizations are not easy to learn; and take time to refine before the young are allowed to participate in the hunt; usually this behavior needs to be learned by the onset of winter (Smith, 2002).
It you check, you can see more mammals are monogamous.