男大学生求前女友复合被拒当众杀人。法院:死刑,并直播绞刑现场!
21岁妹子奈拉(Naira Ashraf) ,就读于埃及北部的曼苏拉大学,是一名大三学生。
今年6月20日上午,奈拉搭乘公共汽车去上学,准备参加期末考试。等她下了车,出现在校门口时,意外突然发生了。
一名年轻男子对奈拉疯狂攻击,殴打她的头部。当奈拉被打晕后,男子又趁机跳到她的身上,持刀朝着颈部和胸部勐刺。
光天化日之下,现场还有三四十名路人,男子竟然如此凶残地攻击一名女生,惊呆了现场人群。等到路人上前制止时,奈拉已经被割喉受伤严重,不幸当场死亡。
此案引发轩然大波,民众纷纷要求严惩凶手。据统计,在埃及,针对妇女的暴力事件呈上升趋势。有人权团体批评当局没有认真预防和调查这些问题。不过在这起案件发生后,埃及地方法院作出了快速行动。
“我们还有60天的时间,来应对对阿德尔做出的死刑判决。”对此,外国网友评论道:“法官,干得漂亮!”
Judge asks for killer who stabbed a student to death for rejecting his marriage proposal to be hanged on LIVE TV in Egypt
- Mohamed Adel, 21, was found guilty of murdering his university classmate Naira Ashraf when she rejected his marriage proposal outside Mansoura University
- He stabbed her several times, in her neck and chest, in the Egyptian city
- The court that sentenced Adel to death has requested to change the law around capital punishment so that the execution of the killer can be aired live
An Egyptian court is planning to broadcast the live hanging of a killer who stabbed a student to death when she turned down his marriage proposal.
Mohamed Adel, 21, was found guilty of murdering his Mansoura University classmate Naira Ashraf when she turned him down, with the court sentencing him to death on July 6.
The court has now called for his execution to be broadcast live to deter similar crimes from happening in future.
In its letter to Parliament, the court wrote: 'The broadcast, even if only part of the start of proceedings, could achieve the goal of deterrence, which was not achieved by broadcasting the sentencing itself.'
Chilling footage shows Adel attacking Ashraf outside Mansoura University near the Nile Delta on 20th June.
She was just about to sit her final exams, according to local media.
Chilling footage shows Adel attacking Ashraf outside Mansoura University near the Nile Delta on 20th June. She was just about to sit her final exams, according to local media
Ashraf died on the spot as angry passersby seized Adel while he was holding the knife and standing over her body, the video shows.
She was stabbed several times, including on her neck and chest, local media said.
The knifeman had stalked the student and had resolved to kill her after she rejected his marriage proposal, the court heard.
Mansoura Courthouse preliminarily settled on the death penalty on June 28, confirming the sentence a week later.
An appeal stalled the verdict, which was made public on July 24. Now, the court has requested that the legislature change the statute governing capital punishment so that the execution might be aired live.
'We still have 60 days to challenge death sentence against Adel,' said the defendant's lawyer Farid El-Deeb.
El-Deeb, who worked as the lead defence lawyer for late ex-president Hosni Mubarak, is well-known in Egypt.
The last time a capital punishment was in 1998, when state television broadcast the execution of three men who had killed a woman and her two children at their home in Cairo.
In Egypt, the method of execution for civilian convictions is hanging.
Ashraf was stabbed several times, including on her neck and chest, local media said
Comments 815
Share what you think
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
Smythe-William, Stopperton, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Bring that judge to our country to deal with the murderous devils we have here!
Dutch Van Der Linde, From a Parallel Universe, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
We need to bring this back in the UK. Live TV of evil people being hanged would make great entertainment
Inthenameoftheweeman, Aberdeen, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Something like that over here would put the message out for nasty criminals
Allcommentscensored, El Dorado, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can this judge give the UK legal system an overhaul?
Hgbackonceagain, Occupied, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Imagine that, actual justice, what a feeling that must be.
iglesias160, new york, United States, 4 days ago
Good and fair sentence. Now had it happened in Britain, the judges would have sentenced him for couple of years and set him free to lead the rest of his life
Realenglish, Devon, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can only dream about British judges giving a sentence as fitting as this.
one eyed deer, nowhere, Heard Island And McDonald Islands, 4 days ago
Now that is justice. Show it here please and then bring the same law here.
Major pane, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
No thats how you do it....it might make the next guy think twice before he murders someone for no reason.
Pammydodger, Somewhere over the rainbow, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Wish we could bring back capital punishment in the UK Im sure it would reduce crime here.
sunnyclimes, Poole, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
The pathetic justice system in the UK needs to sit up and take notice. There is no deterrent in modern sentencing. .A slapped wrist and suspended sentence (no pun intended) are laughable.
dixie broadcasting, Austin Texas, United States, 4 days ago
How to deal with all the these murders Its completely got out of hand with poor small children killed weekly in the UK and US
Pounce the Cat, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can you imagine if he made it to the Uk, there would be protests by the score demanding he not be returned to Eygpt.
Mikemikerophone, Crewe, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good idea should make it ppv with all monies going to girls family
scalia1963, Derby, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
This is where Britain falls so short, they actually punish their criminals.
PITT RIVERS, BOTTOM DRAWER, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Well if I stops another woman dying at the hands of someone thinking they are entitled to kill them - so be it. And I never thought I would say that.
Jedi Master Yoda, Unknown, United States, 4 days ago
Awesome! Something to consider here in the West as well.
Brian Leyland, Lhasa, Nepal, 4 days ago
Oh dear - never mind. He deserves it. RIP beautiful young lady.
Acestriker, Leicester, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Great justice system which should be adopted here as well.
docklands_express, Western_approaches, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
If there is no question he commited the crime, i have no qualms with what the courts request. Good riddance
Brian Anderson, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Will we be able to see the execution in the UK on the TV? Poor lady. RIP to her and condolences to her family.
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
Mr Teleman, Yorkshire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
It should be on pay per view, they'd make a fortune.
andyandy53, Mansfield, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Why can't we do that here in the uk , that would be a real punishment for those that deserve it and a real deterrent
OrganMeats, Atlantis, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Seems fair to me, can we hire this judge for the UK.
Dude Dudester, Northamptonshire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Wouldn't mind watching that. Why should I feel guilty about watching an evil man who killed a beautiful young woman die? I don't.
michaelmobius, london, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Love is not stabbing someone if they say no, at least in terms of minimum conditions
thoughtful man, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Such an incredibly beautiful woman with everything to live for.
Vicki greene, Huntingdon, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Sounds good to me...Bring back Capital Punishment in the UK...
ooold git, Clacton-on-Sea, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
GOOD for Egypt, We should do the same here, instead of putting money into the hands of lawyers & judges who defend them or lets them off with a stern talking to. But it won't happen here because too many people are making too much money out of the taxpayer. Can we import some of their judges & lawyers to this namby pamby, scruffy lawless island
Julie Winters, Leeds, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Such a beautiful woman, what a waste of a life
DaveyboiOK, Manchester, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'm sure she was worth more than her looks, Julie.
life on earth, Primordial Soup, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
His death on live TV will be a deterrent but it's too late to save this poor beautiful girl. At least they have reasonable sentences for barbaric crimes in Egypt unlike the UK, the punishment should fit the crime
Charlie Ladders, Fulham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can we have that here please. Use Wembley Stadium. Sell tickets. Earn a fortune. All proceeds to the NHS.
Quote me 101, Poole, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Im sorry that a young lady lost her life but televising someone being hung is not ok. Its 2022 for goodness sake.
A farmer100, East Anglia, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
So who is the bloke at the end of the motorbike takings? Why isn't he helping?
Its Donna Tolley, Bullyhole Bottom, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'd pay to view that live for sure and hope that style of justice can be introduced to the UK, especially the televising of it.
MultifacetedUserV4, Uni, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Now you see this is justice. Britain should take note!
mallen1952, clacton, 4 days ago
Whilst I agree with the sentence I'm not sure that a live TV event is the right way to go.
Rusty Yeltz, STOURBRIDGE, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'd be happy to pay my tv licence if this was included
Philip1512, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Nice one Egypt. Just a shame Albert isn't still about to do the bib for you!
penny, Hampshire, 4 days ago
The ultimate act of fragile masculinity. Every time a woman turns down a man (even ignoring a cat call), she risks violence because some (not all, blah, blah, blah) blokes just can't take rejection. We need to change this somehow. Guys; when she isn't into you, get over it.
wonnowtsince1995, Liverpool, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Is it really necessary to show those pictures of the poor girl by the side of the road?
CalmDownWokies, Petrograd, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Why show photos of this poor girl laying dead in the street ! Have some decency
Alfred, Herts, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
So many murders in this country as well now. There seems to be little respect towards other peoples lives. The punishment fails as well as it does not deter others. So bring back hanging, I do understand the contradiction because I do value life. Also by life imprisonment I actually feel sorry for the guards spending 40 hours a week having to look after them.
fullofgoodintentions, Somewhere in Yorkshire , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
This is what the British justice system is lacking....... sentences which fit the crime!
JustPlainCommonSense, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
What else can you expect from a country like Egypt?
Mr B Wilson, Blackpool, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Fun fact. The UK government arms sales department, Defence & Security Exports, has identified Egypt as a key market, despite its terrible human rights record. So maybe we provided the handcuffs. Look out for the Union Jack
Sandyhills, Sandy, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
If it happened here the audience figures would go through the roof, great idea to get rid of the sc-m that have taken over our streets
Lefty2020, Waltham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
In the 1970s my late Father in law worked for a firm that won a contract to build a multi-gallows in Saudi Arabia. They built the gallows, and the whole team were invited to be witnesses. My FIL wouldn't attend as he came from Belfast, and had had a belly full of violence, but several of the team did, and he said that they were haunted by it for years. It's hard to say whether it is a deterrent, but we are clearly too soft in the UK.
Golfer doc, Leigh, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Exactly what we need in the UK proper sentences that match the crime.
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
Helen thomas, Chingford, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Their country, their rules,something drastic needs implementing here as crime and murders have never been as bad.
Lord Whiteley, Whiteley, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Death penalty is appropriate for this kind of heinous crime. She must have "dishonoured" him by refusing. Get over it boy. There are a few candidates for this sort of punishment. Executions used to be public events here, perhaps we should reinstate that.
Prof. Hudson McLean, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Excellent example. All sentences must be made public.
yellowbellie 1, CLEETHORPES, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
The correct sentence is given here, when you take someone else's life, in certain circumstance's you should pay with your own.
Gonefishing.., Norfolk, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
The world is too soft on justice! It would be a safer place if their was a better deterrent!
Likeitornot, Bracknell, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
It will probably be popular viewing and no more than he deserves. RIP Naira - you were robbed so cruelly.
Dave Beverley, warwick, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I know it wont bring the poor girl back, its the right sentence though, Id pull the lever my self if it been my daughter!!
Very_Vocal, Tamworth, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I hope they lose an appeal and the sentence is carried out. It would send a message to like minded males.
Pilot Prune, Sunderland, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Makes sense, try it in India where all those awful stories on attacks on women & girls happen.
BlahBlah aka mobair, Hedge End-Southampton, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Fantastic idea! Something must be done to stop the terrible murder rate in the UK! Live hangings! Great stuff!!
Personalityjohn, St austell, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Pay per view hanging .I reckon it could be quite popular. Bet Fred would do quite well. Would definitely brighten the week end up
kittyKat786, Lala land, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Such a beautiful, promising young woman. Male violence against women has to stop.
Vortex of Chaos, Texas, United States, 4 days ago
The sentence is fair but not sure about broadcasting that live - I wouldnt want my kids accidentally turning that on while looking for the Cartoon Network !
Anetcontributor, Cumbria, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Love it. The evidence is 100 percent nailed on. Hang him and let the kids watch. In 10-15 years crime will be low.
DaveSmith43, Somewhere Posh, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
That's what we need here. But we are top soft
Quid est veritas, xxx, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Looks like rejecting his proposal was the right thing to do. He was hardly a marriage material.
MargaretMarkham, Birmingham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I agree with the death penalty for this but not that it should be in public.
VictorMeldrewsDad, By The Seaside Essex, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Proper sentence, British Judges, take note.....
spaceghetto, Spiceworld, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Imagine the crime rates in the UK if we had a decent criminal justice system like this
bazzaboy48, bangor, 4 days ago
Programme idea for channel 4 there, right up there with naked attraction.
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
DoloresFandango, Durham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Poor girl. Would love to visit Egypt again but sadly will never do this for lots of reasons.
Yorkshire Sense, Yorkshire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
That would send a loud and clear rmessage, which is needed in those countries. And increasingly so in ours.
Damiensbdjdjsbhsg, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Do you reckon I could get the channel on satellite
Hobgoblin52, Roseville, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
This type of justice is the only way to stop crime. Prison is no deterrent because in some cases it better than their home life.
PandaGirl12345678910, Somewhere, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Now why did we get rid of hanging in the U.K.?
faible, dublin, Ireland, 4 days ago
should be more of it ..the more the merrier..cheaper than the electric chair,cheaper than a firing squad and its good for the environment when the rope can be recycled for further use,its a win win you will have the eco warriors and snowflakes on side as well
Euphemia III, Lakebank, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
That's what you call justice, excellent idea. Just make it as long and painful as possible, if advertisement breaks are required, no problem.
YossanMehra, Cambridge, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good on that judge. Let that thing swing as an example to others.
EconomicSavvy, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Why not. He took a life he should lose his in front of millions just to show what the consequences are.
Saying It As It Is, Kent, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Offer that judge a job in the UK, NOW! Sick and tired of our weak and enabling so called justice system.
Johny Eng1ander, Manchester, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
One of the few things that better in Egypt than the UK. A just sentence.
Disgusted of Ely, Ely, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
What sort of monster wants execution to be a public spectacle?
Deadly Dazzler, Ilkley, 4 days ago
Beautiful woman who did absolutely no wrong. He deserves this sentence, can't it be broadcast worldwide??
Reallysorrybut.., Newcastle, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
At least her family gets justice not like uk where he would be out in 7 7 years
NeilRich61, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Reminds me of Riyadh's 'Chop Chop' Square on Friday afternoons.
Spirit of Cromwell, Forgotten Up North, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Wish we had a judges that would give real sentences to the criminals in The U.k. Instead we have Micky Mouse sentences with Micky Mouse judiciary.
Its.Raining.Again, A Kardashian Free World, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
"What's on TV to item ma ?" Oh nothing much just a live hanging at 6pm
Bequia1949, Watford, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good,if only we could have some kind of death sentence in the U.K.
Summertime2001, Plymouth, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can we do that here please? All the women who have been killed and children live tv and watch them swing
LadyLike22, Liverpool, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'm totally OK with that sentence and that it be done publicly. Hopefully it will deter other men who think that Women are there only to please some violent, misogynistic men.
CrowStepGable, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good for Egypt. I sincerely hope it serves to save other women in the future. RIP lovely lady. Xxx
Mike Chunter, Stoke, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Fair enough, punishment fits the crime, no soppy justice like you get in the UK.
poshirabit, Birmingham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Great, I'll salute Egypt if they go ahead with this. Just what Britain needs.
busymumof3, Lanarkshire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Well if it gets the point across that violence against women who dont do what you want is unacceptable I cant see a problem.
Roger Stunt, Belfast, Ireland, 4 days ago
Now that's what i call justice. TV ratings will sky rocket, and the Govt/taxpayer will save a small fortune on detaining him. The money saved could then be put into schools/hospitals. Win Win!
Not the last word, Staffordshire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Male pride in some traditions is extremely dangerous to women.
Mac-Clashy, Grimsby, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can we have that here please. A few televised executions will make people think twice before committing this type of crime.
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
Out is out, Kent, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Wonder if we will see it live on the BBC ? British judges and the government take note bring back the death penalty to the United Kingdom
funnyold world, london, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Very few, here are addressing the Public hanging issue. If the sentence of death is given , it should be inside a prison. But then you dont want to get convicted of theft in Egypt, unlike the Micky Mouse UK.
Ting Tong2014, United Kingdom and, Germany, 4 days ago
If you killed someone, you have to be killed as well, it's only fair!
woodhouselad, Mansfield, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
That's why we have so much crime in the UK, no deterent.
Sloopjohnb, Hants, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Now that is what i call a deterrent - well done to Egypt !!!! UK is a laughing stock - short sentences spent in 5 star accommodation (paid for by the UK tax payer) is no deterrent at all.
Leeds17Dave, Leeds, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Do it, a justice system to be afraid and respectful of
Cynic123456, Fed up w DM moderation policy, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good. I hope it's available on a channel broadcast to UK. Perhaps al jazeera will run it.
Voice of reason 66, The Four Winds Bar, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Please remove the photos of the poor girl lying on the ground dying DM. Have some respect for her poor family.
robert christie, bedford, Namibia, 4 days ago
I have , for years , been advocating neck stretching for killers and many more for serious crimes .
gimme those pills, somewhere , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Now we're talking, if only our government had the balls to do the same
Jackthelass, CHESTER UK, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Need this in the UK, killings here have almost become fashionable with not much consequence, they carry knives here because they are cowards , Bring back real punishment,
UrWifeMyKid Returns, dorchester, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
That picture of her lying there is heart breaking...
Roy Wiltshire, Burgh-le-Marsh, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
If this goes ahead the do gooders will be out in force but the truth is it needs to go ahead.The UK needs the return of capital punishment more than many other countries,our stabbings,shootings and death rates are always on the rise,young women found dead and no do gooders demos will stop this the death penalty has to be reintroduced to have any chance of reducing these crimes. Its clear the softly softly approach just does not work,our politicians want to do the right thing for our country give us a vote you will find many of us would vote for this.
Thriller_in_Manila, Number Fifty-Seven, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
It's good to know that at least ONE justice system in that part of the world is treating the memory of woman with respect.
Beefy Goodness, Hamstead, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Shame on you DM for that photo...her poor family must be bereft.
Katludkins, Ashford, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'm all for it! Good! We need capital punishment here asap
Onkelwulf18, Berlin, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
An excellent idea, time the rope was bought back to the UK and should be put to a referendum, would be bought back in a jiffy, instead we let these out of touch idiots in westminster treat us like mugs, time for real change.
OnlineWriter, Unknown, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
R.I.P. gone far too soon! Shame on him! Should be left to rot. The world is just too cruel!
Forever Respectful, Stopathome, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Not a bad idea to teach others consequences
NoneShallPass, UK, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I wish there was a brain scanner of some sort that can weed out all these mentally unstable people in society. It should not be that hard to do. Ask a series of questions, examine brain activity, ignoring what the person says out loud.
Tommy Walker, Foxtrot Juliet Bravo, United States, 4 days ago
As a small child I went with my father to a hardware shop. My father had a conversation with the shop-keeper about a recent execution. This conversation is still with me today and has acted as a moral tale in my life.
luciferleeds, leeds, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
The punishment befits the crime, but I don't agree with making this into entertainment.
Shropsunwokesociety, Burford, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
THIS IS JUSTICE! Exactly what we need in the UK to reduce crime.
Worldisverysinister, Not London thank goodness, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
He took her life he deserves his to be taken in return
optimally optimistic, Warrington, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I think we should take a leaf out of Egypt's book, save a fortune on prison costs and this IS a deterrent.
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
Refuse to be PC, Sunderland, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good, set a precedent and maybe these types of crimes may stop.
soulbeliever666, Little England, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
They dont mess around there, perhaps we should take leaf from there book....
IsraelHands, Off The Shoulder Of Orion, Tuvalu, 4 days ago
Now that is a proper sentence. Here please.
The man from Zanussi, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Bet he will not be so tough on the eternity trapdoor
Sympathyfor theDevil, The Land of Vimto., United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Well done to the Judge. Justice needs to be seen.
Fencesitting, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
ARE YOU WATCHING ENGLAND?? Well done Egypt. I'll tune in
geologyabz74, Lincolnshire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I hope that the judge is successful in his wish.
mikeb , Dunfermline , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
That's the kind of justice system we need!!
2 of 24 repliesSee all replies
chippy saint, Evesham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
There would be far more lost than gained from the reintroduction of the death penalty in the UK. It seems a simple solution but rarely is. It certainly doesn't appear to act as a deterrent and you only have to look at the murder rates in the US to see that.
Sir cumference69, Birmingham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Public hanging? Sounds good, Maybe it will prove to be a deterrent, maybe we should try it here., either way he deserves it, or anything worse they can think of.
SW66Bristol, Bristol, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Not usually in favour of the death penalty, but would make an exception for him!
Keith49, SEVENOAKS, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Beautiful girl in the prime of her life taken far too soon.
Crazy_Curls, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can we bring that judge here please? Ours let baby killers walk free after a month..
The Stinger, Leicester, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Cant see a problem, show it at an appropriate time and those that dont wish to see it dont have to watch it. I doubt it will act as a deterrent though
THE BRICK PROFESSOR, Kent, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
What a beautiful woman , who has been taken by a monster of a bloke .
Familylady, Kent, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Decent sentences, take note U.K. judges stop the decline in behaviour now
They hate the truth, Kent, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Its only right the execution is aired life as a deterrent to would be monsters . I am all for it .
Watson and Holmes, Baker Street, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
At last! True deterrence. Should be displayed world-wide.
PITT RIVERS, BOTTOM DRAWER, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I never thought that I would say this but I agree. The horror of the execution might be the only thing that makes other entitled males stop feeling that they have the right to murder females.
Gyurci, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Well.. in some countries there are proper sentencing practices
2 of 5 repliesSee all replies
someoneswatching.., Cambridge, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
good, sorry to the mothers involved in this. We need to teach our children right from wrong, no matter what the social situation is. You have no rights over another adult human. none.
Arya Stark , islanders , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can that judge mentor our judges? Just saying! Sorry for offending anyone
Batman-999, Gotham City, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Well he took a life now it's his turn no need for snowflakes.
Common Sense Talker, Woke is a Joke., United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Hopefully the Egyptians will make a change to their laws in this case and live stream it without any Geo Blocking.
bluemonkey., Leicestershire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Should do this in the UK for persistent criminals
Kernowforever, South East Cornwall, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
He deserves the ultimate punishment. Would it be a deterrent and would I want to watch it? Don't know is the answer.
Chelseas Drum Kit, MurphsdadSt Prudlingham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Now that IS justice. We should learn from them.
Sicilian black, Siracusa, Italy, 4 days ago
I don't think public hanging will deter someone who is intent to kill but I do agree with the death penalty for this crime.
The comments below have been moderated in advance.
davidhayes44, COVENTRY, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Pity we don't have something similar in the UK then perhaps people may start to think before killing somebody
OccumAndCo, Durban, South Africa, 4 days ago
If showing the sentence carried out on TV live is a deterrent, ie it saves lives, who can oppose it? Give priority to saving lives, not to squeamishness.
SirSlightlyAlarmed, Newcastle, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Go for it - their country - their laws. No problem here.
Hugo Furst, Middle England, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Sounds like a good idea as a suitable deterrent to others. I could think of lots of other Countries that could introduce this type of punishment.
OverPopulatedPlanet, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
This could be the answer to Netflix's problems.
Beth, Swindon, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Poor young girl .. don't think we need those photos, have some respect.
2 of 3 repliesSee all replies
Peter, Raleigh, 4 days ago
Punishment is less of a deterrent if it not seen by the public. Whether Capital punishment or jail, if it is not observed it is not effective. Would so many people be caught speeding for example it the punishment was being put in local stocks or having to be in the High Street with an embarrassing sandwich board...?
Albert Burkhalter, Flensheim, Germany, 4 days ago
Capital punishment is not a deterrence. It is a penalty. it is quite effective at stopping POS who have been caught from committing another crime but will not stop others out there who have no fear of the law and live outside of society.
Perpetually Outraged, Tunbridge Wells, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
We need something like that here too.
Tiddlesmcduck, South East, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I would support this. Might deter the next misogynistic monster from doing the same....
Retired White Male, San Ramon, Costa Rica, 4 days ago
Brilliant. Oh its about time. When this works as a deterrent, others could copy an effective solution. But probably not in wokeland.
gbp_zebedee, Northants-on-the-Edge, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
In our society this may seem brutal but in that society it will be a just punishment and maybe a deterrent. Look at the state of our streets and general behaviour before we begin condemning other governments.
Mikemike1111, Bournemouth, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'm a Catholic but I couldn't agree more. I will subscribe to SKY or BT to watch that evil man go down.
Cassie May, London City, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
There is too many men like this in our world! It makes me sick! Poor beautiful woman. Rest in peace xx
Mikemike1111, Bournemouth, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'm a Catholic but I couldn't agree more. Show it on TV.
Captain Forsight, Wolverhampton, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Great idea, make it pay per view and all the proceeds to go to the victims family.
DisconnectedDB, Dreamland, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I don't disagree with the request, he should be publicly shamed and humiliated in his death but men will still think they are entitled to kill women that refuse them, it is a defect.
valleyroad, Chippenham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
We should have been doing that years ago in the UK, just think of all the lives that would have been saved.
I viam inveniam, Stokesley, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
At last a decent sentence
2 of 5 repliesSee all replies
fraybentos6161, sandbanks, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
take note soft british judges and home secretary.
james, Oxford, New Zealand, 2 days ago
I agree with the judge.
almarsh, Milton Keynes, United Kingdom, 3 days ago
So sad
BINKYBINDI, AD, Australia, 4 days ago
great justice system swift ...no sitting in jail for 40+yrs costing taxpayers millions of $$$$$$$$$$
MJS73, New York, United States, 4 days ago
Now that is Justice !!! No sitting in jail for years with appeals. Watch the crime rate drop lower when people find out they will be swinging by the end of the week. Once they take a life violently , they forfeit theirs automatically. That should be everywhere.
Accidental Berliner, Berlin, Germany, 4 days ago
If it manages to deter just one other would be murderer, sure, let the man hang on television.
RebelForever, Arkansas, United States, 4 days ago
We desperately need to make executions public in the USA!!
Sid 25, Durham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
What a tragic waste of a young life taken away in her prime, well done that judge we need more like him to hand out punishments for crimes like these.
Franks, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Fragile men needs to be punished for crimes like these
Cleveland, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Don't give Netflix ideas!
nina007, Perth, 4 days ago
Good job too... They SHOULD broadcast it !!!
Bold Geezer, Hereandthere, Spain, 4 days ago
Seems fair enough.
Another Day 55, london, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
He is right I support the judge on this
Anglophile3, Atlanta, United States, 4 days ago
Go Egypt - this is the only real justice.
Dr MB, Cardiff, 4 days ago
The judge said he wished the execution would be broadcast live as a deterrent. The court couldnt order that.
Ajax12345, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Justice
IanMoxley, ISLE OF WIGHT , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
We needs justice like that
Boxter, Cleveland, United States, 4 days ago
Put it on Pay per View !!!
jessieblueskies, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
The killer was probably born through generations of arranged marriages that missed out on the getting to know each other and falling in love part - the most important part. The lacking can produce monsters.
fknknowall, Melbourne, 4 days ago
Bring back hanging, It's what the people want.
HDCCTV, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
And this is UK news because?
carlinc, cheltenham UK, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
RIP Beautiful young lady. He does deserve his punishment. How can a man think it's OK to murder a woman because she didn't want to marry him?
Old Cynic, Utopia, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
An appropriate sentence.
charlatans77, wilmslow, 4 days ago
No more than he deserves.
Brianna85, Knightsbridge London , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
This will Deter others
Tara87, Birmingham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Brilliant idea!
luther, oxford, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Where you are caught red handed by multiple independent witnesses, capital punishment should be the only outcome
Tau Ceti, pizzapolis, Italy, 4 days ago
I fully support the decision.
Old Git 1960, Hastings, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Yer good sentence
nemesis49, Staffordshire , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I can understand the death penalty but why broadcast it live !!!!' That is sick
Charlie57, Warrington, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
We should have that sort of sentencing here not the idiot judges we have,
Harry Horse, Somewhere, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
So cruel, hope he rots in hell
Ohwhatfun, Chester, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Just wicked. So sad.
Fark Wad, Londim, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good, put Egypt in charge of our justice system.....and make the BBC show it!
Galaxy Supernova, In a KPOP Wonderland, South Korea, 4 days ago
Getting the punishment he deserves - and get it done as soon as possible
Yves1234, Lancashire , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Beautiful young woman, so sad. I agree with the sentence, we need to do the same
i.will say it anyway, England And Used To Be Proud , United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Why can we not have courts like that here, ones that do their job properly. Rest in peace young lady.
Wellington7, Boston, United States, 4 days ago
I doubt it will be a deterrent. A psycho won't be deterred.
Jetlee1975, Las rug, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Better entertainment than love island
The Fish, Birmingham, 4 days ago
Now that's justice!
Scott J, somewhere, 4 days ago
I'll pay per view for that.
justsaying, Lndon, 4 days ago
Poor family and such a beautiful girl
chippy saint, Evesham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'm not in favour of the death sentence, though I understand the reasons why some might have cause to think differently. However, showing an execution on TV for whatever reason, deterrent or entertainment, is abhorrent.
Steven peckham, Glasgow, 4 days ago
Reintroduce to the uk
Surreal , Seventy oaks, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Where do I watch the hanging?
Geronimo256, Tamworth, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Just the kind of justice needed in Britain
Perenz, Derbyshire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good on the court for doing this.
Geronimo256, Tamworth, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Just the kind of justice we need in Britain ,this would stop all the killings here
DrtobagenMD, Worthing, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Thats one way to do it, and it's better than ours...
Kitcat11, Southampton, 4 days ago
Can this be brought in in this country. Will soon clear the prisons out
Bonvoyage, Dorset, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good idea
lover of music, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I wouldn't want to watch that!
Box56, Bolton, 4 days ago
Wish they would do that here!
Lucaner, Lucan, Canada, 4 days ago
It should be shown on live tv. These losers need to see what real justice is like and not the coddling they get in Britain.
Dubrovnic, Sheffield, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Is it PPV
lisar, aspanaway, United States, 4 days ago
This was done once in the US, think maybe early '90s and a lethal injection, but not positive.
Richard76, Sheffield, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I've no issue with the death penalty but to screen it on live tv? A step too far!
John Span, Cambridge, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I like that
Skogen, The Forrest, Sweden, 4 days ago
People need to be protected and deterrents need to do just that.
Shanice_00, Cardiff, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Hmmm I like this judge. Want a job in the UK?
Jinxyjames2, Middle Of Norhole, United States, 4 days ago
Again, can this be streamed here? Totally worth the watch. Maybe it will catch on here.
Stuart 266, Wigan, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I wish we could rid the world, of these barbaric narrow minded evil idiots. In which will help to keep innocent victims of these barbaric idiots safe.
Sparkysue, Westerham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I bet we won't get to see it! We get warned about distressing scenes coming up on Emmerdale, when it's just someone cry's!
Englishcountryman, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'd watch it!
Jay mcnulty, Malaga, Spain, 4 days ago
No messing about there. Appropriate sentencing.
Spysgirl, Wiltshire, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Absolutely disgusting. Men standing by watching a young girl be slaughtered. ME well deserved sentence for this monster.. we should have it here too .
Countryboyatheart, Folkestone, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Good decision. Might make others think twice before committing such a crime.
urbanrumer, peterborough, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
What time , WHAT CHANNEL ?
Ah Come On, Dublin, Ireland, 4 days ago
Correct decision
HG, where eagles dare, United States, 4 days ago
Those pictures are pretty graphic dm
Hirum, Boksburg, South Africa, 4 days ago
No wokerati in Egypt so a suitable sentance.
The woodchopper, Carlisle, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Hed get a suspended sentence here. If our judges gave half the sentences others do they be in jail more than they are now.
Richard, Rochford, 4 days ago
If you're going to have a death sentence, as a deterent, it's a good idea to show it on TV.
JohnConnor6.6.6, Bouvet island, Bonaire, Sint Eustatius and Saba, 4 days ago
Should make it a regular feature
corruptionrules, Brisbane , Australia, 4 days ago
Excellent idea (better than our judiciary) - should be more of it!!!
picman, london, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I'll watch it
Nadine, Hoorn, Netherlands, 4 days ago
If you can't take no for an answer!
ringo67, peterborough, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
When 100% sure, do the same thing here!
Oldvalues, Liverpool, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Had this happened in the Uk, he would have got a few years after being shown to have psychological problems and a deprived childhood. Go Egypt!
MrTone, Newcastle, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Great! Give the judge a job over here?
Gnrham, Dorset, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I would have that here
Friendy86, Leamington, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Brilliant! That's what should happen in every country
Rudolf-7, Winterthur, Switzerland, 4 days ago
Good and well deserved. RIP lovely lady!
jhope46, norwich, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Great sentence.
NFnN, Normal For north Norfolk, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Fair enough
Ted, Halifax, Canada, 4 days ago
I'd watch.
BAZZA 123, WICKFORD, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Sounds reasonable to me.
Silver glimmer, Airspace, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
UK take note, that is a proper sentence for a despicable crime.
zerobucks, london, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
We don't show murder scenes and victims DM please have the same respect
Megawatt, Stretham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Excellent... we should do similar over here in the UK, the only language some criminals will understand..!
zmg, Ffffff, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Well done judge!
Fir agus Mna, Durham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
I wish we had the same justice system
martnarvy, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Lets hope its live streamed
The Chainsaw, Brexit County, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
It's interesting to see the overwhelming support for death sentences for this sort of crime. So why does Britain pussyfoot with pathetic sentences as low as three and a half years for a murder when it seems most people would like to see a return of capital punishment?
Yes me again, LIVERPOOL, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Can that system be adopted here, please ?
JetA1, Nottingham, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Pay per view
JH66, Manchester, 4 days ago
Result
SJP, Arundel , Spain, 4 days ago
that sort of sentence is a proper deterrent
Sandyshaw62, The world, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Ok with me!
Tiamare, London, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Yes please bring on live broadcast. Needs to be done in countries where they think its ok to take a life just because the woman rejects his proposal.
Ians1978, Oxted, United Kingdom, 4 days ago
Sounds like better viewing than U.K. television!!! Bring it on. I'll hang around to watch it live!!!!!!!!