加拿大 辩论预算法案 反对党撕毁政府的乐观图景
议会沉默，因为 Chrystia Freeland 发出了重磅消息
2024年11月27日
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rtcQRBOnJ_M
这是连续 4 个月通胀率处于加拿大银行目标范围内，通胀率已降至 3 年来最低水平，工资现已超过通胀率，这是一个机会来强调加拿大和美国之间的经济关系是平衡且互利的，比中国、日本、英国和法国加起来还要大，而且我们卖给美国的东西也是他们真正需要的东西，当 Freeland 笨拙地翻阅经济统计数据时，议会爆发出笑声，但在笑声背后隐藏着一个严酷的现实，加拿大人不能忽视，看着反对党领袖撕毁政府的乐观图景，揭露成本上升和暴力增加的真相，这对所有加拿大人来说都是好消息，因为我们今天做出了财政回应，议员们正在辩论预算执行法案，明天，议员们将对这项重要立法进行投票，预算执行法案将实施今年预算中的许多关键措施，事实上，我们需要它们，他们也需要美国，加拿大是美国在世界上最大的市场，这不仅仅是另一场辩论，这是加拿大政治的转折点，在我们继续之前，我想请你帮个小忙，如果你喜欢这个内容，请花一点时间点赞这个视频，并订阅频道，超过 98% 的人观看视频，即使不订阅，你也不需要花钱，但这对我们来说意义重大，所以，你点击了订阅按钮吗，太好了，非常感谢，现在回到视频，当加拿大副总理克里斯萨·弗里兰自信地走上讲台时，会议室一片寂静，她带着自信的微笑，开始滔滔不绝地列举统计数据，描绘出一幅经济繁荣的画面，这似乎好得令人难以置信，事实证明确实如此，弗里兰吹嘘加拿大令人印象深刻的 GDP 增长、低失业率和不断上涨的工资，我们向他们出售石油，我们向他们出售电力，我们向他们出售关键的矿物和金属，美国从加拿大进口的能源在今天比以往任何时候都更加重要，绝对必不可少，因为北美和美国寻求发展具有弹性和安全的供应链，在我们看到人工智能对能源和加拿大关键矿物和金属的渴求时，她声称该国的表现优于其他 G7 国家，通货膨胀得到控制，未来光明，政府席位点头表示同意，但他们几乎不知道纸牌屋即将倒塌，反对党领袖手持一叠文件，眼神坚定，弗里兰结束了她的玫瑰色宣言，他站起来准备挑战每一个主张，房间里的紧张气氛显而易见，他开始逐一驳斥她的论点，他首先揭露了真相加拿大国内生产总值增长的性质表明，它主要是由人口增长而不是实际经济扩张推动的，然后，他撕毁了失业数据，展示了它们如何掩盖了日益严重的就业不足和不稳定工作危机，当反对党领袖继续对弗里兰的说法进行无情的攻击时，意想不到的事情发生了，笑声开始在会议厅中荡漾，它始于周四反对党席位上的几声笑声，我们今天在内阁就此事进行了很好的交谈，我们真的很高兴加拿大人将有这个机会，但很快就像野火一样蔓延开来，甚至一些政府议员也无法抑制他们对这种荒谬情况的嘲笑，反对党领袖还没有结束，他拿出一张又一张的图表，将弗里兰的说法与现实世界的数据进行比较，政府的叙述与现实之间的差距令人震惊，食物银行的使用量猛增，无家可归者人数不断增加，生活成本不断上升正在摧毁中产阶级家庭，随着笑声渐渐平息，议事厅里一片寂静，人们开始讨论假期期间的税收减免，加拿大工薪阶层将能够获得更多的支持，负担得起，这是我们国家现在需要的，我想先分享一些关于我们经济的好消息，通货膨胀率从 3 月份的 2.9% 下降到 4 月份的 2.7%，每个人都知道接下来会发生什么，反对党领袖把他最具破坏性的论点留到了最后，他以外科手术般的精准揭露了政府经济计算中的一个重大缺陷，这个缺陷使得他们的整个叙述变得毫无意义，随着启示录的全部重量沉入地下，弗里兰的脸色一沉，她精心打造的经济成功形象支离破碎，暴露无遗，只不过是烟雾弹和镜子，反对党的长凳爆发出欢呼声，而政府议员则在座位上不安地挪动着，这不仅仅是一个政治摊牌，这是一个关键时刻，对每一个努力争取的加拿大人来说，都会产生深远的影响。尘埃落定后，收支平衡，有一件事变得清晰起来，政府的经济童话终于结束了，弗里兰对加拿大经济的乐观看法在议会大厅破灭了，但真正的重磅炸弹不是百分比或增长率，而是她发表的一条评论，证明了她与加拿大普通民众的脱节程度，为今年你将从政客那里听到的最沉闷的声明做好准备，认识一下来自多伦多的两个孩子的单身母亲莎拉，她正在当地的食物银行排队，这是她从未想过需要去的地方，莎拉的故事在加拿大各地并不罕见，家庭面临着支付房租和购买食物的艰难选择，而弗里兰却吹嘘自己创造了就业机会，莎拉的全职工作几乎无法支付基本开支，政府的乐观统计数据隐藏了一个更黑暗的现实，食物银行的使用量在短短一年内激增了 35%，大城市的无家可归者达到了创纪录的水平，这些不仅仅是数字，还有邻居、同事和朋友陷入困境系统崩溃的裂缝 那么这场经济危机的背后是什么？政府本身的政策 肆意挥霍和印钞导致的失控通货膨胀使生活成本飞涨 被吹捧为环保救星的碳税正在榨干加油站和杂货店里的家庭 让我们不要忘记房地产市场，外国投资者和投机者推高了房价，而加拿大人却无法负担从东海岸到西海岸的自己的城市 温哥华的故事层出不穷 年轻专业人士住在车里，因为哈利法克斯的房租负担不起 老年人为了买得起药而省下饭钱 在农村社区，家庭农场因无法跟上不断上涨的成本和政府繁文缛节而破产 但面对这些严酷的现实，弗里兰的面具在这里真的脱落了 她竟然大胆地建议加拿大人只需要一个 Vibe 会议就能对经济感到更好 你听到了 对的当许多家庭失去家园，在食物银行排队时，我们的副总理认为，一些积极的想法将解决所有问题，这种令人震惊的脱节为反对派领导人要求答案和问责制的最后摊牌奠定了基础，一个问题迫在眉睫，当政府与人民如此脱节时，政府能生存多久，经济童话结束了，加拿大人正在醒来面对一场噩梦，接下来会发生什么可能会重塑未来几年的政治格局，议会中令人震惊的交流揭示了加拿大政治和经济基础的深刻裂缝，弗里兰的失误不仅仅是一个小失误，这是一个政府脱离现实的症状，议事厅里回荡的笑声不仅仅是针对一位政客，而是针对让普通加拿大人失望的 AIST 系统，但真正的问题是，有多少其他政府主张建立在摇摇欲坠的基础上，是时候了每个加拿大人都戴上侦探帽，开始深入研究数字，不要只是接受政客们灌输给你的东西，在我们展望未来时要质疑一切，一个大问题迫在眉睫，加拿大经济能否在领导人似乎更感兴趣的政治宣传而非实质内容的情况下生存下来，答案可能决定数百万努力维持生计的勤劳加拿大人的命运
Parliament GOES SILENT As Chrystia Freeland FIRES BOMBSHELL
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rtcQRBOnJ_M
that is 4 months in a row that inflation has been within the bank of Canada's target range inflation has fallen to its
lowest level in 3 years and wages have now outpaced inflation it was an opportunity to highlight the fact that the economic relationship between Canada and the United States is balanced and mutually beneficial larger than China Japan the UK and France combined it is also the case that the things we sell to the United States are
the things they really need laughter
erupts in Parliament as Freeland fumbles
through economic statistics but behind
the chuckles lies a stark reality
Canadians Can't Ignore watch as the
opposition leader tears apart the
government's Rosy picture exposing the
truth about Rising costs and increasing
violence this is really good news for
all Canadians with our fiscally respon today
members of parliament are debating the
budget implementation act and tomorrow
members will vote on this important
legislation the budget implementation
act would put into effect many key
measures from this year's budget the
fact is we need them and they also need
US Canada is the largest market for the
US in the world this isn't just another
debate it's a turning point in Canadian
politics before we move on I'd like to
ask you a small favor if you appreciate
this content please take a second to
like this video And subscribe to the
channel over 98% of you watch the videos
without subscribing it costs you nothing
but it makes a huge difference to us so
did you click the Subscribe button great
thank you so much now back to the video
the chamber fell silent as chrisa
Freeland Canada's Deputy Prime Minister
confidently stroe to the podium with a
self assured smile she began rattling
off statistics painting a picture of
economic Prosperity that seemed too good
to be true and as it turns out it was
Freeland boasted about Canada's
impressive GDP growth low unemployment
rates and Rising wages we sell them oil
we sell them electricity we sell them
critical minerals and metals the energy
the United States imports from Canada is
more important today than ever are
absolutely essential as North America
and as the US seeks to develop Supply
chains which are resilient and secure at
a time when we see how hungry AI is for
energy and Canada's critical minerals
and metals she claimed the country was
outperforming other G7 nations with
inflation under control and a bright
future ahead the government benches
nodded in approval but little did they
know the house of cards was about to
come crashing down enter the opposition
leader armed with a stack of papers and
a Steely determination in his eyes as
Freeland finished her Rosy proclamations
he rose to his feet ready to challenge
every single claim the tension in the
room was palpable as he began
dismantling her arguments one by one
first he exposed the true nature of
Canada's GDP growth revealing it was
largely driven by population increase
rather than real economic expansion then
he tore into the unemployment figures
showing how they masked a growing crisis
of underemployment and precarious work
as the opposition leader continued his
Relentless assault on freeland's claims
something unexpected happened laughter
began to Ripple through the chamber it
started as a few Chuckles from the
opposition benches on Thursday we had a
good conversation today at cabinet about
that and we are really glad that
Canadians are going to have this
opportunity but soon spread like
Wildfire even some government MPS
couldn't suppress their amusement at the
absurdity of the situation the opposition leader wasn't done yet he pulled out chart after chart comparing
freeland's claims to real world data the
gap between the government's narrative
and reality was staggering Food Bank
usage had skyrocketed homelessness was
on the rise and the cost of living was
crushing middle class families as the
laughter died down a hush fell over the
chamber to have a tax break over the
holidays and that working Canadians are
going to be able to get a little bit
more support with affordability it's
what our country needs right now I'd
like to start though by sharing some
good news about our economy inflation
fell to 2.7% in April down from 2.9% in March
everyone knew what was coming next the
opposition leader had saved his most
devastating argument for last with
surgical Precision he exposed a major
flaw in the government's economic
calculations one that rendered their
entire narrative meaningless freeland's
face fell as the full weight of the
Revelation sank in her carefully crafted
image of economic success lay in tatters
exposed as nothing more than smoke and
mirrors the opposition benches erupted
in cheers while government MPS shifted
uncomfortably in their seats this wasn't just a political Showdown it was a moment of truth that would have far reaching implications for every Canadian struggling to make ends meet as the dust settled one thing became clear the government economic fairy tale had
finally come to an end freeland's Rosy picture of Canada's economy just shattered on the parliament floor but
the real bombshell it's not about percentages or growth rates it's about a comment she made that proves just how
disconnected she is from the average
Canadian struggle brace yourself for the
most toned deaf statement you'll hear
from a politician this year meet Sarah a
single mother of two from Toronto she's
standing in line at the local food bank a place she never thought she'd need to visit Sarah's story isn't unique across Canada families are facing impossible choices between paying rent and putting food on the table while Freeland boasts about job creation Sarah's full-time job barely covers her basic expenses the government's Sunny statistics hide a darker reality Food Bank usage has exploded by 35% in just one year homelessness is at record levels in major cities these aren't just numbers there are neighbors co-workers and Friends falling through the cracks of a broken system so what's behind this economic crisis look no further than the government government's own policies runaway inflation fueled by Reckless
spending and money printing has sent the cost of living through the roof the carbon tax touted as environmental salvation is squeezing families dry at the gas pump and grocery store let's not forget the housing market where foreign
investors and speculators drive up
prices while Canadians are priced out of
their own cities from coast to coast the
stories pile up in Vancouver young
professionals are living in their cars
because rent is unaffordable in Halifax
seniors are skipping meals to afford
their medications and in rural
communities Family Farms are going
bankrupt unable to keep up with Rising
costs and government red tape but here's
where freeland's mask really slips when
confronted with these harsh realities
she had the audacity to suggest that
Canadians just need a Vibe session to
feel better about the economy you heard
that right while families are losing
their homes and lining up at food banks
our Deputy Prime Minister thinks some
positive thinking will solve everything
this shocking disconnect sets the stage
for a final showdown as opposition
leaders demand answers and
accountability one question looms large
how long can a government survive when
it's this out of touch with its people
the economic fairy tale is over and
Canadians are waking up to a nightmare
what comes next could reshape the
political landscape for years to come
this shocking Exchange in Parliament
reveals the Deep cracks in Canada's
political and economic foundations
freeland's fumble isn't just a minor
slip up it's a symptom of a government
that's lost touch with reality the
laughter that echoed through the chamber
wasn't just aimed at one politician but
at aist system that's failing ordinary
Canadians but here's the real kicker how
many other government claims are built
on Shaky Ground it's time for every
Canadian to put on their detective hat
and start digging into the numbers don't
just swallow what the politicians are
feeding you question everything as we
look to the Future one big question
looms can Canada's economy survive with
leaders who seem more interested in spin
than substance the answer might just
determine the fate of millions of
hardworking Canadians struggling to make
ends meet
