Keep Your Eye on the Land Value Ball
There is more evidence that a major crash in residential land prices has been underway. Even reports from less bubbly areas like Minneapolis-St. Paul look ominous.
Values for developable residential land in the metroarea are down about 35 percent from 2005, United said in a preview ofits study that was released this week. The full study will be publishednext month.
In Florida, where land values inflated as much as tenfold from 2000 to 2005, prices have dropped by as much as 50 percent.
“The land market has dried up,” said Alex Barron, ananalyst at JMP Securities in San Francisco. “Most builders are on thesidelines because they expect prices to go down another 30 percent.”St. Joe Co., Florida’s biggest private landowner, said Tuesday that theaverage price per acre of land it sold in the fourth quarter dropped to$1,900 from $4,100 in the third quarter.
In what is becoming a broken record, homebuilders are reportingsubstantial quarterly write offs in land values. This is on top ofearlier very large write downs from homebuilders as reported in this January release.It strikes me as odd that although homebuilders have recognized the bigdrops in land values, the market still doesn’t connect the dots on whatthis means to overall national land values and subsequent collateralfor the debt monster.
The (Lennar) results included charges of $329 million,or $1.33 per share, for a loss of land sales, which included awrite-down of land values and write-offs of deposits on land options.
Meritage who operates mostly in Arizona just wrote off $100 million in land.
KB Homes also joins the hit parade with $308 million in fresh land write offs.
Why does all this matter? Because residential land values dominateaggregate home values, especially in recent years. The long version canbe plodded through here,but the snapshot comes from this graph, showing that land made up 46%of home value at the end of 2005. Also according to this report, theprice of land is three times more volatile than structure pricesthroughout the historic business cycle. But now with land comprised of50% more of the overall home value than in the early 1980’s, the effectof this leverage is even more magnified.
Source: Davis-Heathcote Study
Applying this to actual numbers, there was an aggregate total of$24.1 trillion in home values at the end of 2005, and $11 trillion ofthis was composed of residential land or lots. So when we see thelargest US homebuilders writing off hundreds of millions in land valuesper quarter, and further witness 50% plus drops per acre in St. JoeLand Florida’s land prices, it would pay to take heed. A recentDeutsche Bank report said, “When measured as a percentage of beginningrisky land assets (i.e. excluding standing inventories), our buildersunder coverage wrote off $2.9 billion of risky land assets, or 12% ofbeginning land assets (over the past 12 months). If we extrapolate thisto the $11 trillion total land values from 2005, a good case could bemade that $1.3 trillion in land values has been wiped out. Not minoradjustments, but quite significant towards impacting the collateralbacking the already troubled US mortgage market. It is THE ball towatch.
Finally a chart the begs the question, who is left to even put asmall dent in this? And Barry Ritholtz quoting Stephanie Pomboy on underwater ARMS.
Click here for a listing of all recent Wall Street Examiner blog postings.
